My
sermon title is a reference to Al Gore’s now famous 2006 documentary entitled
“An Inconvenient Truth,” which won two Academy Awards. But let me make it clear
at the very beginning that this sermon is in no way political. Concern for the environment
should transcend politics. In this respect Al Gore may have been the worst
thing that could have happened to the issue of climate change or global warming
because his film and his book “Earth in the Balance” politicized a scientific
issue. He did not intend this to happen, but it happened nonetheless simply because
he is a politician.
Once
again let me say that Al Gore was both the worst thing and the best thing that
happened to the issue of climate change. He was the best thing because he
brought the issue of global warning to the forefront of public discussion. It
was the worst thing because people immediately began to take sides on the issue
based not on the scientific merit of his case but on political party. People
suspected he had a political agenda. If you were a Democrat you agreed with
him; if you were a Republican you disagreed with him. Science took a back seat
to politics, and that is always bad for science. So let me make it clear that what
I have to say this morning has nothing to do with politics. As many of you know
I am not a member of either major political party.
This
morning I am going to be taking about care for the environment in spiritual
terms. Gore also tried to take this approach in his book “Earth in the Balance.”
Gore writes: “The more deeply I search for the roots of the global
environmental crisis, the more I am convinced that it is an outer manifestation
of an inner crisis that is, for lack of a better word, spiritual,” (p. 12). He
defines “spiritual” as “the collection
of values and assumptions that determine our basic understanding of
how we fit into the universe.” (p. 12) That is what I am going to be dealing
with this morning. I am not a scientist, but I am a Christian who is concerned
about what we are doing to God’s creation. Gore is also a Christian. So whether
or not you agree with his politics, he is our Christian brother. He writes: “My
own faith is rooted in the unshakable belief in God as creator and sustainer, a
deeply personal interpretation of and relationship with Christ.” (368) I
believe that the human relationship to the earth is fundamentally a spiritual
issue. How we treat the earth flows from our spiritual worldview. That is why I
am addressing it in a sermon. It was also requested in a Summer Sermon
Suggestion.
In
the interest of full disclosure for those who are climate change skeptics, I
admit up front that I believe that the scientific evidence is overwhelming that
the earth’s climate is warming up. I also believe that the evidence points to the
likelihood that humans have played a role in that change. Even though people
use the issue for their own partisan political agendas – liberal and
conservative – if we put that aside, I think that the science behind global
warming is irrefutable. I also suspect that the increase in short term extreme
weather events that we are seeing around the world and in our country - from record heat, wildfires, hurricanes,
floods and tornadoes - may be the result of this long term climate change
pattern, although that connection needs more documentation.
But
I am not going to be talking meteorology today; I going to talk about theology
and spirituality. I am going to be presenting some of the Bible’s inconvenient
truths about the earth and humans’ relationship to it. I am using Jesus’
Parable of the Unjust Steward as my text to expound these truths.
I.
The first truth is that the earth belongs to God. The earth is not ours to do
with what we want; we are the earth’s, and we and the earth belong to God, the
Lord of the heavens and earth. Jesus’ story begins, “There was a certain rich man who had a steward, and an accusation was
brought to him that this man was wasting his goods.” I think Jesus’ story
can be applied to our environmental situation. The rich man represents God, and
man is God’s steward. The accusation is brought that the steward is wasting the
owner’s goods. In this same way we can say that the earth is the Lord’s and we
have been wasting his earthly goods. In the Psalms David makes it clear who the
earth belong to. “The earth is the
Lord’s, and everything in it, the world, and all who live in it.” (Ps.
24:1) The Lord also says to Job, “Everything
under heaven belongs to me” (Job 41:11). Psalm 104:24 declares, "The earth is full of Your
possessions." In 1 Chronicles 29:11 we read, "Yours, O LORD, is the greatness, the power and the glory, the
victory and the majesty; for all that is in heaven and in earth is Yours."
The
Earth is God’s creation and possession. This an inconvenient truth because many
people – religious and nonreligious – wish that were not true. People would
rather have the earth be ours to do with what we want. Even Christians have twisted the Bible to
give ourselves permission to misuse the earth, just like Christians in the
American South used the Bible to justify the institution of slavery. In fact
many nonreligious people have blamed the present environmental on Christianity.
They point to the Genesis command for man to “have dominion” over all living
creatures on the earth as the root of all our modern problems. In Ian McHarg’s
frequently quoted book (Design with Nature, 1969) he describes this
passage (Genesis 1:26,28) "as one
text of compounded horror which will guarantee the relationship of man to
nature can only be destruction …. The Genesis story in its insistence upon
dominion and subjugation of nature, encourages the most exploitative and
destructive instincts in man, rather than those that are deferential and
creative … God’s affirmation about man’s dominion was a declaration of war on
nature."
Lynn
White wrote in his paper ‘The historical roots of our ecologic crisis’ (Science,
155: 1204-7, 1967). "We are superior to nature, contemptuous of it,
willing to use it for our slightest whim … Both our present science and our
present technology are so tinctured with orthodox Christian arrogance towards
nature that no solution can be expected from them alone." It is true that
Christians have been a part of the problem, just like nonchristians have been.
But it not correct to blame the Bible for our present situation. Any fair examination
of the whole Bible – and not just selected proof texts - will reveal that the
Bible teaches that the land and animals are to be cared for and treated with
respect. On the other hand Christians also blame the secularism and humanism of
Western society with its view of nature as a machine and no more than a
backdrop for technological advancement and commercial development as the
problem. That is not completely true either. It is inconvenient to both of
these worldviews to see what the Scriptures really teach. That the world is
God’s creation, that it is pronounced good, and that humans are part of that
creation.
II.
That brings me to Christianity’s second inconvenient truth. Humans are not just
part of God’s creation, they have a God-given role that no other species has:
to be stewards of God’s creation on this earth. Humans are made in the image of
God, which means they are to be God’s representatives on this earth toward the
natural world.
There
are two creation stories in Genesis. One in chapter 1 and the other in chapter
2. People will quote the first and not the second, but to get the whole story
you have to have both. The first story God makes humans in his own image and
then says to them, “Be fruitful and
multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea,
over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the
earth.” (1:28) People critical of Christianity interpret subdue and
dominion in a violent destructive abusive sense. Nothing could be further from
the truth. If you read how this command was applied in the rest of the laws of
the OT you see it was meant in the sense of cultivate the land and domesticate
the animals for human use, and to care for those animals not for human use.
That is the whole point of Noah’s ark! Why put all these “unclean” animals that
humans cannot eat or use on the ark? The whole purpose of the ark was to
protect all living animals on the planet – whether or not they were useful for
man. The second creation story in Genesis 2 makes it clear when it says “Then the Lord God took the man
and put him in the garden of Eden to tend and keep it.” (2:15) He was to
tend and keep all the plants and trees, to make it a beautiful garden on earth,
which meant in this chapter to stay completely away from some of the trees.
I
know you can make the Bible say whatever you want it to say. Shakespeare wrote
“the devil can cite scripture for his purpose.” But if you look at all the
evidence then it is clear that the Bible does not give humans a license to
strip the earth and abuse it, to decimate whole species, but instead instructs
us to care for the flora and fauna of earth as God’s stewards.
III.
This brings me to my third inconvenient truth – that we are accountable to God.
In Jesus’ parable, the steward was supposed to take care of the master’s goods,
but he does not. “an accusation was
brought to him that this man was wasting his goods. 2 So he called him and said
to him, ‘What is this I hear about you? Give an account of your stewardship,
for you can no longer be steward.’” We are to give an account before God
for how we have fulfilled his instructions as a human race. There is a need for
confession and repentance here. I don’t see a whole lot of confession and
repentance happening on the national political scene when it comes to the
environment. This is where the Christian church can play a leadership role.
When you hear discussion about protecting the environment, reversing global
warming and protecting endangered species, all the talk is about the effect of
environmental policies on economics and politics and international relations.
They
mostly have to do with economics – what it is going to cost us. Is it going to
help us or hurt us as a nation? There is a lot of talk about what is fair in
regard to each country, the developing world and the industrial world, and what
other countries are doing or have to do. I don’t hear a lot of talk about
accountability to God. That is where religion can play a role. We have been
given a job to do on this earth from the very beginning by the CEO of the
cosmos. Our task on this little planet is to “tend and keep it.” In the midst
of our economic problems and our international relations we have lost sight of
the big picture. Before there ever was a United States or a China or a European
Union, human beings were assigned a task to do – to care for our common earthly
home - and we are not doing it. To use the words of the parable, word has come
to the owner of this planet that his stewards are not doing their job, that we
are wasting God’s resources. The man in the parable calls his steward to
account. “So he called him and said to
him, ‘What is this I hear about you? Give an account of your stewardship, for
you can no longer be steward.’
IV. This
is Christianity’s fourth inconvenient truth. We are in danger of being fired from
our job as stewards. In this parable there is an apocalyptic urgency to take
action. If you want to know what that might look like if we don’t act, then
read Alan Weisman’s book “The World Without Us.” It describes what the earth
would be like if human beings were no longer present. Wilderness reclaims urban
areas. It turns out that it is not so bad for the earth. Considering how we
have been destroying habitats, poisoning the ocean, and extinguishing species
of animals, maybe we are doing more harm than good to God’s property. Remember
these animals are God’s not ours. “For
every beast of the forest is Mine, And the cattle on a thousand hills.” (Psalm 50)
I
have had the misfortune of being a landlord at various times in my life, both
seasonal rentals and long term. If you have ever rented property to tenants
then you know that some tenants treat your property with respect and others destroy
your property. One of the tenants we had in our little in-law apartment in
Pennsylvania ruined the place. It had to be completely redone to make it
livable and rentable again. I ended up kicking the guy out, which is not an
easy thing to do legally these days. We are God’s tenants here on this planet.
God is the landlord – the Lord of the land. Not only are we the tenants, but it
was our job to be the caretakers of the property – live-in caretakers. We are
assigned the task of managing the property. Look what we have done to the
owner’s property! If I were the owner and landlord I would begin legal action
to kick us out of the job and off the property. Maybe that is what God has in
mind. It seems to be the message of this parable, and not only this parable.
Jesus tells a number of apocalyptic parables about people who are judged for
not fulfilling their duties.
Look
what the steward does in the parable. When he learns that his judgment day is coming,
he panics. He says in verses 3-4 “Then
the steward said within himself, ‘What shall I do? For my master is taking the
stewardship away from me. I cannot dig; I am ashamed to beg. 4 I have resolved what to
do, that when I am put out of the stewardship, they may receive me into their
houses.’” Then he spends the little time he has left before he has to leave
scrambling to make amends the best he can. He tries to recover as much as he
can for his boss in as short a time as he possible can. He doesn’t care if he
is not getting the best return on the investment, he is just trying to save his
own neck. When the owner finds out what the steward did, he praises him for his
shrewdness, cleverness, and creativity. He says in verse 8 “So the master commended the unjust steward because he had dealt
shrewdly. For the sons of this world are more shrewd in their generation than
the sons of light.”
This
is what is needed in regards to environmental issues today. The ‘sons of this
world” are doing more than the church to care for the earth’s environment. People
don’t feel any sense of urgency when it comes to this topic. We are more
concerned with homeland security and the world economy than the environment. The
average person is more interested in family, job, personal finances and health
concerns. In this presidential election I don’t hear the issue raised much.
There is no sense of urgency. That is because politicians don’t feel they are
accountable to anyone but the constituents who elect them and the individuals
and groups who give them the most money. I see little sense of accountability
to God.
Only
the church feels any accountability to God, and not even then all the time. To
be honest, with the shrinking role of the church’s influence in society I don’t
know if our call to be accountable to God on this issue can be heard. The
church seems more concerned with the morality of contraception than the fact
that we might be making the planet uninhabitable for our descendants. The
consequences of not taking environmental action seem too far down the road for most
people to worry about right now. We have more important issues to attend to.
That seems to be the prevalent. But that doesn’t mean we can give up. It means
that we need to be faithful to what we know to be true. To do our task as
stewards on this earth as God’s people, to keep repeating these inconvenient biblical
truths at this time in history.